WhatsApp

Kidney Cancer: Size and Spread Decide the Operation

Shah’s Gastro, Cancer & Robotic Surgery Centre

Tapping Book on WhatsApp will likely open the WhatsApp app on your phone.

Last updated: 02-Nov-2026

Assessment, surgery and follow-up for renal cell carcinoma · Gota OPD, Gota, Ahmedabad · Apollo Hospital, Bhat, Gandhinagar

IN SHORT

Most kidney cancers are found by chance on a scan done for something else. A lump in the kidney is checked with a proper multi-phase CT before anyone plans an operation.

For a small tumour the aim is to take out the tumour and keep the kidney. Removing the whole kidney is kept for tumours that cannot be removed safely in any other way.

A tumour that has spread is treated with medicine first. The choice of medicine depends on a risk score, and on what the family can sustain.

The kidney that is left behind matters as much as the tumour. Its strength is measured before surgery, not guessed.

Dr Swati Shah, kidney cancer surgeon, Ahmedabad

Dr Swati Shah
MS, DrNB (Surgical Oncology)
Kidney Cancer Surgeon
Apollo Hospital, Bhat, Gandhinagar · Gota OPD, Gota, Ahmedabad · 18 years of experience
★★★★★ 4.99 from 84 Google reviews (Gota clinic) · 5.0 from 37 (Apollo, Bhat)

Who writes this page. Dr Swati Shah holds MS, DrNB (Surgical Oncology). She studied medicine and trained in general surgery at Maulana Azad Medical College, Delhi, and trained in surgical oncology at Rajiv Gandhi Cancer Institute and Research Centre, Delhi. She has 18 years of experience in cancer surgery and has worked on the robotic console since 2013. Consultation, assessment, surgery and follow-up run as one pathway.

Every kidney tumour larger than a small one, every case with a clot in the large vein, and every case that has spread, is discussed at a tumour board first. The board has a cancer surgeon, a medical oncologist, a radiation oncologist, a radiologist and a pathologist. The order of treatment is settled there. It is not one surgeon’s call.

This page is about how the decisions are made. The choice between removing part of the kidney or all of it, and what each does to kidney strength, is set out on partial or radical nephrectomy and kidney function.

How a kidney tumour is usually found

Most tumours are found by chance, on an ultrasound or a CT done for another reason. They rarely hurt in the early stage.

The old picture of a kidney cancer, with a lump in the flank, pain and blood in the urine together, is now uncommon. By then the tumour is large. Today most people are told about a shadow on a scan done for stones, a liver check or a fever.

  • Red urine without pain needs a full check of the kidneys, the urine tubes and the bladder. It is never put down to infection without a scan.
  • Odd blood results can be the first clue: anaemia that does not respond to iron, a high calcium level, or liver tests that are off with a normal liver on the scan.
  • A new swelling of the veins of the scrotum, especially on the right side and not flattening when lying down, can mean a clot is growing up the kidney vein. It is looked into the same week.

What the first visit and the scans settle

The first visit answers three questions. Is the lump a cancer, how far has it gone, and how strong is the other kidney.

The key scan is a CT with contrast taken in several phases, including one before the dye is given. Without that first picture, nobody can tell whether the lump takes up dye. A single-phase scan can mistake a bleed into a cyst, or a fatty growth, for cancer.

What the first visit covers, and why it is done then
At the first visitWhy it is done then
CT of the belly in several phases, with and without dye.It shows if the lump takes up dye, where it sits, and whether a clot has entered the kidney vein or the large vein beneath the heart.
CT of the chest.The lung is the commonest place for spread. A plain chest X-ray misses small deposits.
Kidney function by blood test, and a split-function scan when the other kidney is in doubt.One creatinine value is not a kidney assessment. The scan shows how much each kidney does, so the surgeon knows how much can be spared.
Blood count, liver tests, calcium and general fitness.These feed the risk score used if the cancer has spread, and they decide how much surgery the body can take.
A needle biopsy, only when the answer would change the plan.It helps before heat treatment, before medicines for spread, or in an older person where surgery is in doubt. It is not needed for a lump that is plainly cancer and fit for surgery.
An MRI, when the level of a clot is unclear.The top of a clot decides which surgical team must be in the room.

Stage and what it means

The stage is a map, not a verdict. It decides the operation, and it gives a fair idea of what to expect.

The four stages and what each usually leads to
StageWhat it looks likeWhat is usually advised
Stage I.A tumour inside the kidney, up to the size of a lime.Take out the tumour and keep the kidney. Watching or heat treatment for the smallest, in the frail.
Stage II.A larger tumour, still inside the kidney.Removal of the kidney, or of the tumour alone where the position allows.
Stage III.Growth into the fat around the kidney, the kidney vein or the large vein, or into a nearby gland.Removal of the kidney, with the clot if present. Added medicine after surgery is discussed in some.
Stage IV.Growth into a neighbouring organ, or spread to a distant one.Medicine first. Surgery on the kidney or the deposit only in selected people.

The grade, meaning how aggressive the cells look under the microscope, matters as well. An aggressive look calls for more caution at any size.

Saving the kidney: when and how

Taking out only the tumour is the standard for a small kidney cancer. Every avoidable removal of a whole kidney is a step towards kidney disease later.

The tumour is cut out with a thin rim of normal kidney. The kidney is repaired with stitches in layers, and the blood supply is shut off for as short a time as possible. A very thin clear edge is enough for safety. Taking more kidney for reassurance only weakens the kidney.

  • Robot-assisted or keyhole route. Partial nephrectomy is done on the robotic console at Apollo Hospital, Bhat. The cancer operation is the same as in open surgery. The route is chosen for your scan and your body.
  • The blood supply is clamped as briefly as possible. A short clamp time protects the kidney. Sometimes only the branch to the tumour is clamped, or none at all.
  • Agreed in advance. You consent beforehand to full removal, in case the tumour cannot be taken out safely. It is rare, but it is better discussed first.
  • A medicine rule that protects the kidney. Painkillers of the NSAID kind are avoided after the operation, because they are the commonest cause of a rise in creatinine that could have been prevented.

Watching, heat treatment, or removing the whole kidney

Not every small kidney tumour needs the knife at once. The right choice depends on size, age, other illness and the other kidney.

The options for a small kidney tumour
ChoiceWho it suitsWhat to know
Partial nephrectomy.Most people with a small or medium tumour whose position allows it.The standard choice. It keeps the most kidney strength. A short stay and a quick return to work are usual.
Active surveillance.The smallest tumours, or people for whom an operation carries too much risk.Repeat scans at fixed intervals. The plan changes if the tumour grows quickly, crosses a size limit, or you wish it.
Heat or cold treatment through a needle.Older or unfit people with a small tumour, a single kidney, or tumours in both kidneys.A biopsy comes first, as a separate step. It is not used for tumours near the centre of the kidney or for larger ones.
Radical nephrectomy.Large tumours, tumours that sit where a partial operation is unsafe, and those with a clot in the vein.The whole kidney is removed. The adrenal gland and the lymph glands are taken only when they look involved on the scan or at surgery.

A clot in the large vein

Some kidney cancers grow up the kidney vein into the great vein of the body. This is never an operation planned on the day.

The top of the clot is mapped on a scan and given a level. A low clot is handled by the urology team. A clot that reaches the liver or the heart needs cardiac and vascular surgeons, blood-saving equipment and a heart-lung machine on standby. Those arrangements are made before a date is fixed.

When the cancer has spread

Medicine comes first for spread. A risk score is worked out before the first dose, because it guides the choice.

The score uses six simple items. They are how well the person is, how soon medicine is needed, and four blood counts. It sorts people into favourable, intermediate and poor risk.

  • Immunotherapy combinations are now the guideline standard for most people. They are costly. We set out the benefit and the cost side by side, and note the conversation, even when the family chooses another route.
  • Tablet-only treatment with a drug that blocks the tumour’s blood supply is the usual real-world choice in India. It is an accepted option for people at favourable risk.
  • Operating on the kidney when it has spread is no longer routine. It is offered to a selected few: good general health, a low burden of spread, or a kidney tumour that bleeds or hurts.
  • Removing a few deposits, especially in the lung, is a real route to long control in a fit person. It is considered actively and not dismissed.
  • Bone spread is protected with bone-strengthening medicine and, where a bone is at risk, with an operation to support it before it breaks.

Medicine after surgery for a high-risk tumour

One immunotherapy drug has been shown to help people after surgery for a high-risk clear cell cancer. It is costly, and it is rarely covered by insurance.

It is given every three weeks for about a year. Other medicines tried after surgery did not help. The benefit is real but modest, and side effects can need admission. The family hears the cost and the gain together.

Risks and the certainties

Risks are named here in words. Your own figures are given in person before consent, for your disease and your fitness.

What is certain, and what is a risk
WhatWhat it means
After a full removal, one kidney does the work of two. Certain.Most people live well on one kidney, but the reserve is less, and the other kidney must be protected for life.
Bleeding during or after the operation.Watched for in the first days. Some need blood, and a few need a second procedure to stop it.
A urine leak after a partial operation.Seen in the drain fluid. It usually settles with a tube placed for a while. Few need more.
A temporary rise in creatinine.Common after a partial operation, as the kidney is stunned. It usually recovers, and is checked early.
A clot in a leg vein or the lung.Prevented with blood thinners, early walking and stockings. Treated promptly if it occurs.
Risk to life.Real in a major operation, and higher with a large clot, weak kidneys or poor nutrition. Your own figure is given in person.
  1. Heavy blood in the urine, or unable to pass urine. Come the same day. A clot may be blocking the bladder.
  2. Fever, or a wound that leaks or swells. Checked on the same day, not at the next visit.
  3. One leg swollen, painful and warm, or sudden breathlessness. Treated as a clot until a scan says otherwise.
  4. Back pain in someone with a known kidney cancer. The spine is imaged before you are told to move freely, because a weakened bone can break.

Follow-up and the years after

Kidney cancer can return late, even after many years. Regular scans and kidney tests are part of treatment, not an extra.

What follow-up looks like
WhoWhat is done
Low-risk tumour after surgery.A visit with kidney function and a scan at set intervals in the first years, spaced out later. The chest is imaged along with the belly.
Higher-risk tumour after surgery.Closer scans in the first two to three years, as most returns occur then. Follow-up goes on for longer than for low-risk disease.
On surveillance or after heat treatment.Scans at the first few months, then at fixed intervals. A growth rate or size limit triggers a change of plan.
On medicine for spread.Scans every few months and blood pressure, thyroid, liver and kidney tests as the medicine requires. Side effects are managed early.
At home.Keep the blood pressure and sugar under control, avoid unprescribed painkillers, drink water, and stop tobacco. Report blood in the urine on the same day.

The reviews below are Google reviews of this surgeon from families treated for kidney cancer. No two people have the same disease or the same plan.

What patients and families have said

★★★★★

“We are very thankful to Dr. Swati Shah for successfully operating on our relative for kidney cancer. From the first consultation to the surgery and follow-up, she was very supportive, caring, and explained everything clearly. Her expertise and confidence gave our family great reassurance during a difficult time. We are happy with the treatment and recovery. Highly recommended Dr. Swati Shah for her dedication and excellent care.”

— Naween. Soni, Google review

★★★★★

“Dr. Swati Shah is an exceptional Robotic Uro-Oncosurgeon. My experience with the robotic partial nephrectomy was excellent. She explained the condition and procedure clearly, and the surgery was performed with great precision. Highly recommended for anyone seeking advanced robotic kidney surgery.”

— Hitesh Shrimali, Google review

★★★★★

“My relative recently underwent robotic surgery for kidney cancer under the care of Dr. Swati Shah, and the experience was exceptional. Dr. Swati’s precision, confidence, and calm approach made a huge difference. She explained everything clearly, guided us at every step, and handled the surgery with outstanding skill. The robotic technique meant smaller cuts, less pain, and a much faster recovery than we expected. We are truly grateful to Dr. Swati Shah for her expertise in robotic kidney cancer surgery and highly recommend her for kidney cancer treatment.”

— Paresh Undhad, Google review

These are shown exactly as Google holds them. They describe one family’s experience, and no two people have the same disease or plan.

Cost, insurance and admission

The cost depends on the treatment, the route and the length of stay. A written estimate is given before admission.

Apollo Hospital, Bhat, Gandhinagar works with the major insurers and with cashless cover, and its office handles the pre-authorisation. Immunotherapy for spread, or after surgery, is usually outside what insurance pays, and we raise this at the first visit. Please bring every scan with its films, any biopsy report, recent kidney tests, your medicine list and your insurance card.

Frequently asked questions

My scan shows a lump in the kidney. Is it definitely cancer?

Not always. A bleed into a cyst, a fatty growth or an infection can look similar on a single scan. A multi-phase CT with a picture before the dye separates them. A needle biopsy is added only when it would change the plan.

Will my whole kidney have to be removed?

Not for most small and medium tumours. The tumour is cut out and the kidney kept, wherever it can be done safely. Full removal is kept for large tumours, awkward positions and tumours with a clot in the vein.

Can I live normally with one kidney?

Most people do. The reserve is lower. Blood pressure, sugar and painkiller use need care for life, and kidney tests are repeated at each follow-up.

Why is a split-function scan sometimes asked for?

It shows how much work each kidney does. If the other kidney is weak, or you have only one, it tells the surgeon how much kidney must be saved.

Is watching a small tumour safe?

For the smallest tumours, and for people at high operative risk, yes, with scans at fixed intervals. The plan changes if the tumour grows quickly, crosses a size limit, or you prefer an operation.

Is robotic surgery needed to save the kidney?

No. Keyhole with the robot and open surgery both remove the tumour in the same way. The route is chosen for your scan, your body and safety.

Are the new immunotherapy medicines necessary?

They are the guideline standard for spread, but they are costly. A tablet-only course is an accepted route, especially at favourable risk. We set the benefit and the cost side by side and the family decides.

Which symptoms need a call on the same day?

Heavy blood or clots in the urine, or being unable to pass urine. Fever with a leaking wound. A swollen painful leg, sudden breathlessness, or new back pain. Do not wait.

Where Dr Swati Shah sees and operates

Shah’s Gastro, Cancer & Robotic Surgery Centre

Dr Swati Shah — MS, DrNB (Surgical Oncology) · Kidney Cancer Surgeon

Consultation: Gota OPD, Gota, Ahmedabad. Surgery: Apollo Hospital, Bhat, Gandhinagar.

Gota OPD — Gota, Ahmedabad, Gujarat. Directions

Apollo Hospital, Bhat, Gandhinagar — Apollo Hospital International Limited, Plot No. 1 A, GIDC Bhat Industrial Estate, Bhat, Gandhinagar, Gujarat 382428. Directions

Call: +91-63590-11009 · WhatsApp: +91-63590-11009

People travel to Ahmedabad for this surgery from across Gujarat, southern Rajasthan and western Madhya Pradesh.

Found a lump in the kidney on a scan? Send the scan films and report ahead, with your latest kidney function test. The consultation then starts with them already read. The plan is made after examination, and at the tumour board. Call +91-63590-11009 · Bring the reports to the visit

Tapping Book on WhatsApp will likely open the WhatsApp app on your phone.

Get health updates from Dr Swati Shah on WhatsApp

Swasth Parivar: every week, practical advice on recovery, diet and warning signs. No advertising. Stop any time.

Your number is used for these updates and for the clinic to reach you. It is never sold or passed on. To stop, reply STOP on WhatsApp.

dr swati shah - uro & gynec cancer surgeon
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.